Advanced Studies
Gifted Identification

Multiple criteria are used in order to identify students as gifted in CMS. Students have the opportunity to identify as​ Academically Intellectually Gifted (AI), Intellectually Gifted (IG), Academically Gifted (AG), Academically Gifted-Math (AM), or Academically Gifted-Reading (AR).  Identification decisions are guided by the CMS Gifted Identification Rubric (available for download below). 

 
The chart provides descriptors for the various gifted identification areas in CMS.

Identification AreaDescriptionPathways to Identification 

Academically
Intellectually
Gifted
(AI)

Student demonstrates high intellectual capacity and high academic performance. 

     Student accumulates a minimum of 12 points through… 

     Aptitude;

     Aptitude and achievement; or 

     Aptitude and informal assessments


Intellectually 
Gifted
(IG)
Student demonstrates high intellectual capacity but has not yet demonstrated high academic performance. 

●     Student accumulates 6 points through aptitude but does not identify as gifted in any other capacity after aptitude, achievement, and informal assessment opportunities.



Academically 
Gifted 
(AG)



Student exhibits high performance capability in reading and math and possesses a strong capacity for learning.
●     Student accumulates a minimum of 12 points through…

○     Aptitude, achievement, and informal asssessments

○     Achievement and informal assessments

●     Student earns required points on the CMS Portfolio Scoring Matrix.
Academically Gifted - Reading
(AR)
Student demonstrates strength in the area of reading with substantially high levels of accomplishment.
●     Student accumulates a minimum of points on the CMS Gifted Identification Rubric through the verbal aptitude percentile and reading achievement percentile.

Academically Gifted - Math 
(AM)
Student demonstrates strength in the area of mathematics with substantially high levels of accomplishment. 
●     Student accumulates a minimum of 6  points on the CMS Gifted Identification Rubric through the quantitative or quantitative/nonverbal (QN) aptitude percentile and math achievement percentile.
 

Second Grade Gifted Screening Process

CMS conducts a universal screening for all second grade students primarily educated within a general education setting. The screening utilizes multiple criteria to create a comprehensive student profile. Each second grade student is provided with the Cognitive Abilities Test (CogAT), a nationally normed abilities test, Measures of Academic Progress (MAP), an achievement test, and the Gifted Rating Scales (GRS), an observational checklist. A portfolio opportunity is available if students meet certain criteria.
 

Kindergarten and First Grade

If a kindergarten or first grade student is identified as gifted in any capacity in another school or district, gifted identification will remain the same in CMS. No further testing is required. An Individualized Differentiated Education Plan (IDEP) will be developed for gifted kindergartners and first graders and TD Teachers will work collaboratively with classroom teachers and parents to determine how to best meet social, emotional, and academic needs.

Parents, guardians, students, counselors, teachers, and other stakeholders may refer students to be screened for Horizons or grade acceleration. For students in grades K-1, if the TD Site-Based Committee has enough qualitative and quantitative data to determine the child is consistently performing one to two grade levels above his/her current grade level the following two screenings can occur-- grade acceleration or Horizons.
 

Third-Twelfth Grades

Parents, guardians, students, counselors, teachers, and other stakeholders may refer students for testing for gifted identification in grades 3-12. Each school is required to have a TD Site-Based Committee, which is comprised of an administrator, TD Teacher or
Academic Facilitator (AF), classroom teacher, and other relevant staff members. All decisions for testing for gifted identification outside of the district-wide second grade screening process are made by TD Site-Based Committees. Students may be considered for rescreening by the district after a period of at least 24 months has passed. The CMS Gifted Identification Rubric is used to determine gifted eligibility.
 

Reciprocity for Gifted Identification Outside of CMS

Gifted Identification from another North Carolina (NC) Local Education Agency (LEA)

If testing results led to student being identified as gifted in any capacity (AI, AG, IG, AR, AM), gifted identification will remain the same in CMS with no further testing required. If identification label does not transfer through PowerSchool, a parent or guardian signature will be required on a Talent Development Referral and Results Form to ensure proper coding.

Gifted Identification provided by a school district or LEA outside of NC

If a student was identified as gifted in any capacity (AI, AG, IG, AR, AM) in a school district or LEA outside of North Carolina, gifted identification will remain the same in CMS with no further testing required. Documentation must be provided and may consist of an official score report, educational record, and/or official letter from school or district to show student was identified as gifted. The TD Teacher or Academic Facilitator will complete the top portion of a Talent Development Referral and Results Form and obtain a parent or guardian signature to ensure informed consent and proper coding in PowerSchool.

CMS no longer accepts private testing results conducted by outside licensed psychologists for gifted identification. 
 

Alternate Assessments

Students who, according to their Individualized Education Program (IEP) or Section 504 Plan, cannot take this type of standardized testing with or without accommodations or modifications or whose necessary accommodations or modifications are not available with, or appropriate for this testing, will be screened for gifted identification through alternative assessments.
 
 

Resources & Documents

Procedure to Resolve Disagreements.pdf






Questions?

Contact Kenneth Hiroshige.
P.O. Box 30035
Charlotte, NC 28230-0035
Phone: 980-343-3000
The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools website (www.cms.k12.nc.us) is in compliance with Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act and Title II of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Any website accessibility concerns may be brought via the following, Email the Web Accessibility Team at WebAccessibility or Call: 980.343.0115. In compliance with Federal Law, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools administers all education programs, employment activities and admissions without discrimination against any person on the basis of gender, race, color, religion, national origin, age, or disability. Inquiries regarding compliance with Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972, which prohibits discrimination on the basis of sex in education programs or activities, may be referred to the District's Title IX Coordinator at titleixcoordinator or to the Office for Civil Rights, United States Department of Education.